Research Article - Onkologia i Radioterapia ( 2021) Volume 15, Issue 3

Hypo fractionated radiotherapy for early glottic carcinoma: Feasibility and toxicity

Rasha Abd El-Ghany Khedr and Lamiss Mohamed sad*
Department of Oncology, Tanta University, Egypt
*Corresponding Author:
Lamiss Mohamed sad, Department of Oncology, Tanta University, Egypt, Email: [email protected]

Received: 14-Feb-2021 Accepted: 16-Mar-2021 Published: 26-Mar-2021


Introduction: for early stage glottic cancer, different schedules had been applied. The use of hypofractionation seems to be attractive for shorter overall treatment time and decreased cost of treatment. The aim of our trial is to study the local control and survival rates of hypo fractionated radiotherapy schedule of 55Gy/20 fractions with 2.75Gy/fraction. Methods: T1-2 N0 glottic squamous cell carcinoma was treated at Clinical Oncology department, Tanta university hospital between February 2015 and January 2018. All patients were treated with a schedule of 55Gy/20 fractions/4 weeks. Patients for whom surgery was done whether cordotomy or stripping using laser have been removed. Local control, regional control, and overall survival probabilities were determined. Results: This phase II prospective study, forty-one early stage glottic cancer patients who had fulfilled inclusion criteria were identified. The median follow-up time was 30 (range 5 - 64) months. T1 and T2 disease were reported in Twenty (48.8%) and 21 (51.2%) patients Complete response was reported in (40/41) 97.5 % patients. Five-year actuarial local control rates were 75.1%, 80.8%, 75% and 71.6% in overall, T1 a, T1b and T2 respectively (p=0.977). After the initial full clinical response, a total of 8/40 (20 percent) patients experienced disease recurrence with a median recurrence period of 19 (range 4-59) months after the initial complete clinical response. The 5-year OS were 83.7%. A total of 6 (14.6%) deaths occurred during follow up. Univariate covariate analysis did not show any important association (all p>0.05) with local control. Only one significant covariate associated with overall survival was trans glottic extension in T2 disease (p<0.019). Grade 3 skin toxicity was reported in 4 (11%) patients. Enteral nutrition using nasogastric tube was reported in 7 (17%) patients with grade 3 mucositis. Conclusions: This study had shown that a regimen of 55Gy /20 fractions/4 weeks achieve reasonable late toxicity with good local control for early glottis cancer.


glottic cancer, radiotherapy, hypofractionation


Squamous Cell Carcinoma (SCC) of the larynx is the most common type of head and neck cancer in represents 4.5% of all head and neck malignancies [1]. Globally, the total 5-year overall incidence rates is 154,977 male cases and 22,445 female cases in 2018 [2].

Glottic cancer is diagnosed at an early stage (Tis-T1-T2), more frequently than other laryngeal sites, due to the early onset of clinical symptoms, such as speech hoarseness and dysphonia. Different conservative treatment modalities are effective in early glottis cancer as Radiotherapy (RT) [1], transoral laser surgery [3,4] or Partial Laryngectomy (PL) [5], especially if the anterior commissure is involved, with good and similar functional and oncological results among these treatment options.

Definitive radiation therapy is an established treatment modality for patients with early laryngeal carcinoma [6] aiming for cancer cure, vocal cord preservation with acceptable voice quality, and minimal morbidity and mortality. Definitive RT achieves most of these goals in patients with early glottic carcinoma, and salvage laryngectomy is preserved for relapsed cases with local control rate of 90%-100% for recurrent cases after initial radiation therapy [7-9].

Several dose-fractionation schedules for radiotherapy are used to treat early laryngeal carcinoma. [10,11]. The use of hypo fractionated RT regimens became more common since a randomized trial from Japan [12] demonstrated that better local control rates with such treatment modalities [13]. While noticing that short fractionation regimes remain the less common practice worldwide, hypo fractionated schedules were successful, with less strong evidence based than that for traditional fractionation [14].

There are many preferred schedules as 64-70Gy in 2 Gy/ fraction/6.5-7 weeks, 54-55 Gy/20 fractions/4 weeks, or 50- 52.5 Gy/16 fractions/r 3 weeks for only small volume disease [14]. Schedules using 2.25 Gy/ fraction were also proposed in a related era (to a total dose of 63-65.25 Gy) [12, 15].

The aim of hypo fractionation regimens is to minimize tumour repopulation during irradiation. In view of the small field sizes, which allow higher fractional doses without increased late morbidity; this is especially interesting for early glottis cancer [14]. The history of United Kingdom (UK) audits has shown that in cases of early glottic cancer the higher fraction dose e.g. 2.75 Gy in schedules of 55 Gy/20 fractions had been used, [16, 17].

Published data was limited for hypo fractionated schedule of glottis cancer. We will investigate the hypo fractionated radiotherapy regimen in dose of 55Gy/20 fractions/4 weeks in T1/2 glottic carcinoma in Egyptian population.

Patients and Methods

This is a prospective phase II research conducted at Tanta University Hospital between February 2015 and January 2018. Eligible patients are over 18 years old with histologically proved early glottic SCC, T1-2 N0 M0. All patients in the study preferred definitive radiation therapy after explanation of other treatment modalities and signed an informed consent. The protocol was approved by the ethical committee. Patients with recurrent early glottic carcinoma after laser surgery or cordotomy were excluded.

For all patients in the ENT Department, Tanta University, a comprehensive physical examination, including mirror examination and biopsy of all suspected biopsy with direct laryngoscopy with assessment of vocal cord mobility was performed.

High-resolution CT or MRI of the neck with contrast was done for all patients for detection of supra or infra-glottic or lymph node metastases. If LN metastases were suspected, PET CT scan and FNAC of suspicious cervical LNs were done and positive cases were excluded.

Radiotherapy technique

All patients were put in the supine position with extended neck and fixed by a thermoplastic mask. Virtual CT simulator was used for simulation with CT cuts ≤ 3 mm.

The Gross Target Volume (GTV) was contoured to encompass all suspicious lesions identified from data obtained from laryngoscopic and imaging studies.

The full larynx, including both anterior and posterior commissures and the arytenoids, was covered by the Clinical Target Volume (CTV). The Proposed Objective Volume (PTV) was a three-dimensional expansion of 0.5 cm-1 cm around the CTV. Near the carotid arteries, this margin can be reduced to as little as 0.3 cm. The same boundaries used in traditional radiotherapy are the upper and lower borders. For any patient, no elective neck irradiation was used.

The PTV's superior boundary extended to the notch of the thyroid. Depending on the tumour point, the inferior degree differs. The inferior boundary of the PTV was at the bottom of the cricoid cartilage for T1 N0 tumours. The inferior border extended an additional 1 cm for T2 N0 tumours, particularly with subglottic extension to include the first tracheal ring.

In patients with relatively short necks, angled opposed lateral fields angled 5°-10° inferiorly to avoid the shoulders.

Fifteen or 30° wedges have also been used to ensure a more homogeneous dose distribution. For unilateral lesions, the beam entering from the tumour side was more heavily weighted. The CT planning system used was (Eclipse treatment planning system v13.7).

Bolus was used according to the discretion of the clinician and was generally considered for disease in which the anterior third of the vocal cord or the anterior commissure is compromised, if any part of the PTV in this area is receiving an inadequate dose.

The energy used for treatment was 6 MV photons using CLINAC Linear accelerator, with multileaf collimators (UNIQUE) to a total dose of 55 Gy per fraction of 20 fractions, 2.75 Gy per fraction, given 5 days/week for 4 weeks.

Follow up

During follow up, patients were followed once a week, and then monthly for the first two years afterward, the follow up increased thereafter. The toxicity was graded according to Radiation Therapy Oncology Group (RTOG) toxicity criteria [18].

Statistical analysis

Local control, regional control, and overall survival were evaluated using spss version 21. For the following variables, univariate analysis was performed: age, sex, smoking, alcohol intake, grade, T stage (early versus advanced stage) and cord mobility.


This prospective phase 2 study included Forty- one patients with early squamous cell carcinoma glottic cancer. Patient, tumour and management characteristics are summarized in Table 1. Twenty (48.8%) patients had T1 and 21 (51.2%) patients had T2 disease. Thirty-five (85.4%) patients underwent a contrastenhanced staging CT of larynx and the remaining patients (14.6 %) underwent an MRI larynx. Hypofractionated radiotherapy in dose of 55 Gy/20 fractions in 2.75 Gy/fraction. The tumour biological effective dose estimated for the schedule is 67Gy [14]. The median follow-up time was 30 (5-64) months.

Tab.1. Patient characteristics

Characteristics No of patients (range or %)
Mean age   62 (30-79)
Sex Male 37 (90)
Female 4 (10)
Alcohol Never 26 (63.4)
Current 15 (36.6)
Smoking Yes 34 (82.9)
No 7 (17.1)
Performance status 0 5 (12.2)
1 17 (41.5)
2 14 (34.1)
3 5 (12.2)
T stage T1a 16 (39)
T1b 4 (9.8)
T2 21 (51.2)
Grade Well diff 15 (36.6)
Mod-poor 26 (63.4)
Extension Subglottic 8 (19.5)
Supraglottic 9 (22)
Transglottic 4 (9.8)
No 20 (48.8)
AC involvement Involved 18 (34.9)
Not involved 23 (56.1)
Cord mobility Mobile 22 (53.7)
Impaired 19 (46.3)

Median duration of radiotherapy was 26 (range 24 to 32) days. In three patients, the length of treatment was greater than 28 days (32, 33 and 34 days). The reason for delay was treatment toxicity.

Disease and survival outcomes

Complete clinical response was reported in forty (97.5%). Salvage total laryngectomy was done for patients with refractory disease. The 5-year local control actuarial rates were as follows: 75.1%, 80.8%, 75% and 71.6% in overall, T1a, T1b and T2 respectively (p=0.977).

After the original full therapeutic response, A total of 8/41 patients (19.5%) patients experienced disease recurrence. The median time to recurrence was 19 (range 4-59) months. The recurrence trends are summarized in Table 2.

Tab. 2. Pattern of recurrence and treatment

Outcomes  Patients No (%)
Complete response to radiotherapy 40 (97.5%)
Persistent disease 1 (2.5 %)
Local Recurrence only 5 (12.2%)
Regional recurrence only 2 (4.9%)
Combined locoregional recurrence 1 (2.5%)
Salvage treatment  
Partial laryngectomy 4 (10%)
Laser cordotomy 2 (4.9%)
Total laryngectomy ± neck 1 (2.5%)
Radical neck dissection 2 (4.9%)

After median 18 month follow up period after radiotherapy, local recurrence occurred in five patients only. Three patients developed regional neck recurrence, one of which was in combination with recurrence at the primary subsite.

Details of salvage treatments were shown in table 2. A total of 7/9 patients with persistent and recurrent disease underwent salvage surgery. Bad performance status and patient preference lead to failure of surgical salvage in two patients. Disease free and alive was reported in 6/7 patients (85.7 %) who underwent salvage surgery.

The 5-year OS were 83.7%. During follow up, six patients (14.6 %) died. The causes of deaths were: recurrent larynx cancer, second cancers and death from other reasons. Figure 1-3 illustrates 5-year local control, and overall survival outcomes. Univariate analysis of covariates did not show any significant correlated with local control (all p>0.05). Only one covariate was significantly correlated with overall survival: Trans glottic extension in T2 disease (p<0.019) (Table 3).


Figure 1: 5-year local control


Figure 2: 5-year local control, according to tumour stage


Figure 3: 5-year overall survival

Tab. 3. Univariate analysis of local control and overall survival prognostic factors

Factor Local control   Overall survival
X2 CI p-value X2 CI p-value
Sex 0.5   0.48 0.499   0.48
Alcohol 1.78   0.183 1.036   0.309
Smoking 0.27   0.604 0.004   0.949
Performance status 6.48   0.09 4.238   0.237
T stage 0.05   0.977 2.704   0.259
Grade 0.3   0.587 0.011   0.916
Extension 4.62   0.202 9.998   0.019
Anterior commissure involvement 0   0.977 0.036   0.849
Cord mobility 0   0.956 0.88   0.348

Toxicity outcomes

Reported RTOG grade 3 skin toxicity occurred in 4 (11%) patients. Enteral nutrition through nasogastric tube reported in 7 (17%) patients with grade 3 mucositis. In the first three months post radiotherapy, no death was reported Postcircoid stenosis was reported in only one patient managed with repeated dilatation. Three years after radiotherapy, one patient reported stridor for which tracheostomy was done. Long-term enteral feeding was not necessary in any patients. Enteral feeding was not necessary in any patients for long duration. One patient (2.5%) developed second malignancy (soft tissue sarcoma) infield in left neck, 5 years post-radiotherapy (Table 4).

Tab. 4. Treatment toxicity

Toxicity G I/II  No (%) GIII/IV  No (%)
Mucositis 26(63.4 %) 6(14.6 %)
desquamation 30(73.1%) 5(12.1%)
ulceration 2(4.9%)  
Dysphagia 4(9.7%) 2(4.9%)


Accelerated repopulation has a dismal impact on the radical radiotherapy treatment for early glottic cancer. To reduce the repopulation, shortened overall treatment time had been proposed in the form of hypofractionation

An increase in overall treatment time reduced local and/or regional control for head and neck SCC; evaluation of two studies had shown that in larynx cancer with negative cervical lymph nodes, an additional dose of 0.8Gy/day is required to track tumor growth with increased overall treatment time [24]. Hypofractionation or hyperfractionation with multiple daily fractions had been used to decrease the overall treatment time.

Biological effective dose of three for a schedule of 55Gy/20 fractions is 105.4 Gy for late reacting tissues in contrast to 116.6Gy for standard fractionation schedule of schedule of 70Gy i/35 fractions. It implies a possible therapeutic benefit for hypofractionation. Hypofractionation is an appealing technique with a limited target volume and thus a small mucosal volume for early glottal cancers.

The effects of using a hypofractionated schedule of 55 Gy in 20 fractions, 2,75 Gy per fraction with high local control rates and acceptable treatment related toxicity. recorded in our single institution research.

Five-year local control rates from many research were compared [14, 19-23] utilizing hypofractionated radiotherapy protocols for T1-2 N0 SCC of the glottis. Schedule heterogeneity led to difficult comparison due to difference in tumor stage T1N0 disease versus T2N0 disease or T1-2N0 and variable outcome measures.

Ermis et al. [14] reported the results of a similar fractionation schedule and reported the results of 132 patients with T1-2 N0 glottic cancer. Five-year regional control, and OS rates were 95.4%, and 78.8% respectively. The prognostic factors with statistical significance were age and trans glottic extension in T2 disease.

Also, Chera et al. [23] who performed meta-analysis of 11 large studies which consisted of both standard and hypo fractionated radiotherapy schedule on T2 glottic cancer. Five-year local control rate T1a, T1b and T2a and T2b were 82%-94%, 80%-93%, 62%-94% and 23%-73% respectively. Nearly consistent with that reported in our study, 80.8%, 75% and 71.6% for T1a, T1b and T2 disease respectively (p=0.977).

Few organizations have documented that insufficient evidence of use of fraction sizes greater than 2.5 Gy for T2 glottic cancer. Gowda et al [25], two hundred T1 glottic cancer patients 50- 52.5Gy/16 fractions/3 weeks (fraction 3.12-3.28Gy); 93% overall 5-year local control. Cheah et al [10] T1N0 glottic carcinoma hundred patients treated with a similar schedule of 50Gy/16 fractions/ 3 weeks; 88% 5-year local control.

Laskar et al. [21] single institution using multiple fractionation schedules for T1 glottic cancer reported acceptable local control among them the fractionation schedule of 50-55Gy/15-16 fractions. Short et al. [26] T1/2 glottic carcinoma comparing 60-66Gy/30-33 fractions against 52.5-55Gy/20 fractions/4 weeks showed that The 5-year locoregional control was 75% versus 95% for T1 disease in favor of second schedule. In cases of T2 stage glottic cancer no difference in local control rate. Using 2.25 Gy/fraction had shown modest regimen as hypofractionated schedule. Yamazaki et al. T1 glottic cancer in 180 patients randomized to receive standard fractionation 60- 66Gy /30-33 fractions (2Gy/fraction) or hypofractionation in dose of 62.25-63Gy/25-28 fractions (2.25Gy/ fraction). With 77% versus 92% five-year local control, respectively. So increase the dose per fraction improved the local control rate [12]. T1/2 glottic cancer 585 patients treated of whom 61% of patients received ≥2.25Gy/fraction. Overall local control rates compared favourably with other studies with 5 year local control rates was 94%, 93%, 80% and 70% in T1a, T1b, T2a and T2b, respectively [27]. Treatment gaps more than forty-one day resulted in inferior disease outcome. Le et al multiple fraction sizes results were examined. Among which fraction size of 2.25 Gy was associated with good local control for T2 tumours [28]. Regardless the total and overall treatment time , the fraction size increase appeared to increase the local control with acceptable toxicity in early glottic cancer. [20-29]. There are several limitations to our study. As with other studies, with long term follow up, it is difficult to define whether the recurrence is new disease or local failure. But in our studies, we classified the cases as recurrence Comparison with other studies is difficult due to different TNM classification versions used [23]. Carotid sparing using Intensity Modulated Radiotherapy (IMRT) techniques is of importance [30-31]; the late cerebrovascular events could not be accurately recorded with traditional radiotherapy in our research.


In synopsis, Optimal fractions and early-glottic cancer treatment time must be established. This study showed the strong local control with an appropriate late toxicity for early glottic cancer in 55Gy/20 fractions/4 weeks.


Editors List


    Submitted PhD thesis in Biotechnology at GITAM University, Vizag.

  • Yousef Alomi

    Yousef Alomi
    The Past Head, General Administration of Pharmaceutical Care at Ministry of Health,
    Saudi Arabia Critical Care/TPN
    Clinical Pharmacist Ministry of Health,
    Riyadh, Saudi Arabia.

  • Osamu Tanaka

    Osamu Tanaka
    Assistant Professor,
    Department of Radiation Oncology
    Asahi University Hospital
    Gifu city, Gifu, Japan

  • Maher Abdel Fattah Al-Shayeb

    Department of Surgical Sciences, Ajman University, UAE

  • Andrzej Zdziennicki

    Institute of Gynecology and Obstetrics, Medical University of Lodz, I Clinic of Gynecology and Gynecological Oncology (Lodz, Poland)

Google Scholar citation report
Citations : 61

Onkologia i Radioterapia received 61 citations as per Google Scholar report

Onkologia i Radioterapia peer review process verified at publons
Indexed In
  • Scimago
  • MIAR
  • Euro Pub
  • Google Scholar
  • Medical Project Poland
  • Cancer Index
  • Gdansk University of Technology, Ministry Points 20